Brand Overview

4,179 reviews across 54 products

Executive summary

4,179 Amazon reviews of 54 Devoted products, up to May 2026. Issue counts come from fixed keyword rules, and every number links to the reviews behind it. How this is measured

What are customers telling us?

Mostly good things: 69.5% of reviews are 4–⁠5★, averaging 3.92★.

They love scent customers love (36.3%), moisturizing / skin feel (14%) and fast, dark results (6.4%) of 4–⁠5★ reviews.

They complain about product effectiveness (13.8%), streaking / orange / staining (10.5%) and fragrance complaints (10.4%) of the 1,269 1–⁠3★ reviews.

What are the biggest risks and opportunities?

  • Risk: 125 reviews describe skin reactions, recurring on 10 products. Most affected: Somewhere On A Beach, Fuel My Fire and White 2 Bronze Tingle.
  • Risk: 74 reviews question authenticity across 22 products, led by Famous Faces and Black Obsession.
  • Opportunity: Scent is the most-praised thing in the range (1055 reviews). 58happy customers say it’s cheaper than buying at the salon, which is a ready-made listing message.
  • Opportunity: 3 products are rated higher recently than before: White 2 Bronze Pomegranate, Vacay Vibes and Famous Faces.

What should we focus on first?

  1. 1

    125 reviews · 23 products · safety issue that recurs on 10 products

    Most affected: Somewhere On A Beach (31), Fuel My Fire (20), White 2 Bronze Tingle (16)

    Do: Pull the linked reviews into a formulation and safety review, check them against the ingredient list and batch records, and add a patch-test warning to the listing while that runs.

    Owner: Formulation & Safety

  2. 2

    175 reviews · 33 products · raised in 13.8% of 1–⁠3★ reviews

    Most affected: Somewhere On A Beach (38), Famous Faces (33), White 2 Bronze Tingle (10)

    Do: Spell out on the listing what results to expect and after how many sessions. Check whether the complaints cluster on a few products, which would point to a formula problem, or spread across the range, which points to wrong expectations.

    Owner: R&D & Product Quality

  3. 3

    133 reviews · 20 products · raised in 10.5% of 1–⁠3★ reviews

    Most affected: Black Velvet (43), Black Obsession (22), White 2 Bronze Coconut (12)

    Do: Add how-to-apply guidance to listings and inserts (exfoliate, wash hands, drying time), and check bronzer levels on the products with the most mentions.

    Owner: R&D & Product Quality

Full issue & opportunity matrix

Brand Rating

3.92★

Average across all products

Total Reviews

4,179

Amazon reviews analysed

Positive Reviews

69.5%

Rated 4★ or 5★

Products Analysed

54

Devoted Creations SKUs (+4 external, tracked separately)

Marketing takeaways

What the reviews mean for content, targeting and spend. Counted with the same fixed keyword rules as above, Devoted products only. How audiences are counted

Optimize content: lead with what customers praise

Set expectations: 175 unhappy reviews say the product didn’t work for them. State results and number of sessions plainly in listings and ads.

Improve targeting: who is happiest

Average rating by audience, compared with the brand average
AudienceReviewsAvg
Outdoor / sun tannersFavourite: Ride Or Tide (4.88★)1804.38★
Tanning-bed usersFavourite: Prismatica (5★)3894.14★
Fair or sensitive skin1474.12★
Repeat buyersFavourite: Cloud Kissed (4.9★)3424.10★
First-time tanners1084.06★
Salon customersFavourite: Color Me Coco (5★)3014.00★

Brand average: 3.92★. Aim ads at the audiences above it, with their favourite product.

Marketing decisions: where to put spend

Promote

Hold ad spend until reviewed

Promote = highest-rated products with at least 30 reviews and no recurring skin-reaction pattern. Hold = products where skin reactions recur, since ads would send more buyers into the same problem.

Cross-Product Themes

Frequently mentioned

  • Pump and dispenser failures
  • Unsealed, tampered, or counterfeit bottles on Amazon FBA
  • Fragrance intensity and scent polarization
  • Burning, tingling, or extreme heat sensations during use
  • Persistent hand/skin staining that requires extended washing or makeup remover
  • Product efficacy mismatch: no visible tan or color change despite repeated use

Voice of the Customer

Real reviews from Amazon customers · select a star rating to explore

★★★★★May 2014

“I've been using this product for several years now and I completely love it. It smells great and goes on nicely, hydrates your skin, and doesn't leave a nasty film. Can't ask more from a "manly" moisturizer.”

William M. JohnsonHIM HYDRATE
★★★★★May 2026

“I have only used it once since it arrived but I love it! It's thick and I don't have to use as much as other brands. It smells great, even after . It doe not leave a heavy greasy feeling. Very happy with this hybrid lotion for my hybrid bed. Will definitely purchase again.”

shanna brownCOLLAGENETICS 2 IN 1 LOTION
★★★★★Jul 2024

“I've used this lotion both indoor and outdoor tanning. It definitely helps me tan quicker. And I actually really like the smell! Some tanning lotions leave you smelling weird after tanning. This lotion does not. I'll definitely buy again!”

Amanda W.SOMEWHERE ON A BEACH
★★★★★Sep 2024

“I have tried a million and one different brands of indoor tanning lotions. This is THE BEST ever. A few tanning sessions using this product before our family vacation...and i was the tannest (is that a word? ) of the entire family I will definitely be buying again”

Jace F.FUEL MY FIRE
★★★★★Jul 2021

“I purchased this lotion after trying a few out this season and researching and reading a ton reviews let me just say WOW this lotion did not disappoint I used for indoor tanning and i definitely noticed a difference after the first use it has a pleasant light scent the lotion is not super thick but there’s a lot in the bottle and a little goes a long way also this product I recieved came with a sticker and a phone number to guarantee the authenticity of this product which is a piece of mind if your on the fence for the price I feel like it won’t disappoint you loved this product will definitely be purchasing more when I get low”

JessicaTURQUOISE TEMPTATION
★★★★★Aug 2023

“I love the way this smells. It’s clean and subtle. Great moisturizer. I keep buying more when I use up what I have.”

Kelly EricksonCOLLAGENETICS SPA RESTORATIVE MOISTURIZER
★★★★★Apr 2025

“Don’t sleep on this product! It is amazing! I used it one time and can see a huge difference. I’ve used Designer Skin products for years and triple JWOW this past year and they have nothing in this product!”

Jennifer PenningtonPRISMATICA
★★★★★Apr 2023

“This bronzing lotion is a good moisturizer, and has a great scent. It’s a great value for the money, and I would recommend this product.”

KaseyRIDE OR TIDE
★★★★★Jan 2020

“Smells great; non greasy”

Sharyn WardSALTWATER SUNDAYS
★★★★★Mar 2026

“Love the smell and finished look for this product”

KerryALL BLACK EVERYTHING