SALTWATER SUNDAYS
“Saltwater Sundays is a lightweight, fast-absorbing moisturizer that extends your tan without any greasy residue, though its fragrance can be polarizing.”
Authenticity — Marketplace Concern
Recurring pattern2 reviews report that the Amazon-purchased bottle smells noticeably different from the same product bought at a tanning salon — one describes the Amazon version as "more perfumy" with a strong perfume smell versus a more fruity salon scent (and includes a side-by-side bottle photo), the other says the Amazon bottle "smells nothing like" the salon original and has a "cleaning product-like" smell. Neither claims outright counterfeiting — this reads as possible batch variation, a supplier/formulation change, or degradation in storage, and is worth monitoring as a marketplace-integrity signal.
Negative reviews span Aug 2018–Mar 2026
Based on unverified customer accounts in Amazon review text, not confirmed medical or lab findings.
Avg Rating
4.49★
92 reviews
Positive
83.7%
Rated 4★ or 5★
Neutral
8.7%
Rated 3★
Negative
7.6%
Rated 1★ or 2★
Sentiment Score
82/100
positive
What Customers Love
Moisturizes skin without greasiness or heaviness
“It's not greasy and smooths on nicely. I took it on vacation for my after sun lotion and it did not disappoint.”
Lightweight, absorbs quickly, non-sticky texture
“It does absorb pretty fast. Moisturizes but not greasy. Light scent, and absorbs quickly.”
Effective for extending and maintaining tanning results
“This lotion is healing & smells so good!!! Love this to help extend my tan”
Cooling sensation and soothing feel after sun/tanning
“Love the cool feeling of this lotions! Especially after being in the pool or on the river!”
Customer Feedback
AI summary. Numbers in it are the model’s estimates; counted figures are in Issue evidence below.
Scent is polarizing—described as perfume-heavy, chemical, animal-like, or overly floral rather than authentically beachy
Experience“The smell of this is soooooo perfumed smells like laundry and old lady. It literally burns your nose”
Pump/dispenser mechanism fails or breaks during use or arrives non-functional
Product Failure“Never a good sign when the pump won't work: First thing I noticed once I had managed to remove the cap/pump was the smell.”
Product arrives already dispensed or leaking into packaging
Product Failure“Smells great, but it was squirted everywhere when delivered: While this product smells great and hydrates great, it come with quite a bit already squirted out into the bag/box.”
Scent inconsistency between salon and Amazon bottles—suggests possible batch variation or reformulation
Authenticity“I absolutely love the smell of the bottle that I bought at my tanning salon but it was pretty pricey. I looked it up on Amazon and it was considerably less money...Well, I got it and it smells nothing like my or”
Packaging arrives damaged or without protective material inside box
Product Failure“Completely sealed in plastic wrap, box undamaged ...no packing material inside. I haven't unwrapped it to see if the bottle itself is damaged but what a mess.”
Issue evidence
How these are countedCounted from this product’s 92 reviews with fixed keyword rules. Click a count to read the reviews.
Complaints (1–3★ reviews)
- Packaging / dispenser55.4%Recurring
- Fragrance complaints44.3%Recurring
- Skin reactions11.1%Isolated
- Price / size value11.1%Isolated
Praise (4–5★ reviews)
- Scent customers love3740.2%Recurring
- Moisturizing / skin feel2223.9%Recurring
- Fast, dark results11.1%Isolated
% is the share of all 92 reviews. Recurring means 3+ reviews across 2+ different months. Listing: ASIN B0752X4L4K
Action Items by Team
Supply Chain & Fulfillment (2)
- HIGHRequire QA testing of 5% of inbound stock (test pump 3 times) before FBA shipment — 5+ reviews report pump/dispenser failure.
- MEDIUMAdd bubble wrap or air pillows inside shipping boxes — multiple reviews report bottles arriving exploded or squirted out in transit.
Customer Service (2)
- HIGHReply to scent-inconsistency reviews with a replacement offer and ask whether it matches the salon version or still differs.
- LOWPin a reply to scent-complaint reviews acknowledging the floral/perfumy profile is intentional and offering a refund if unhappy.
Listing Content & SEO (1)
- MEDIUMAdd listing line: 'Sweet aquatic florals with peppermint top note (not a salty/coconut beach scent)' — 9+ reviewers found scent mismatched.
Review Themes
Formula excellence (non-greasy), Scent polarization (perfumy vs. beachy), Pump/dispenser failure, Shipping/packaging damage, Batch/scent inconsistency, Fast absorption, Effective tan extension, Price-to-value ratio
Product Details
Key Features
• Daily Body Moisturizer • After Sun Care • Skin Softening and Hydrating • Soothing Peppermint & Green Tea • Sea Salt & Coconut • Aloe Vera Crème Gel • Hypoallergenic/ Nut Free/ Wheat Free/ Vegan Formula • Sea Salt Breeze Fragrance
All Reviews
All 92 Amazon reviews for this product are shown here for review · filter by star rating below
Showing 71 of 92 reviews · 5★ only — tap another rating below to switch
Clean smelling
Very nice, clean scent. Although I do not use a tanning bed, I do use this lotion. Feels silky smooth and smells nice and clean.
— Kathy T.
Great lotion!!
This lotion is healing & smells so good!!!
— Terri
Love the scent
Love this scent. I’m sorry that I don’t know how to describe it. And the lotion itself, the actual formula, is lovely. It does a nice job of moisturizing without being heavy or sticky.
— vs