BLACK VELVET
“Black Velvet delivers fast, deep natural-brown color without an orange cast, though its thick formula can stain hands and clothing.”
Safety — Flagged for Review
Isolated report1 isolated report of hands turning grey/green after first use ('EXPIRED! Turned my hands grey/green!') and 1 isolated report of severe itching causing skin damage ('it made me literally scratch my skin off!'). Neither report explicitly links to an allergic reaction or indicates a systemic formula defect; the grey/green hands review is attributed to a possibly expired product. The itching complaint is a single data point without evidence of recurrence in other reviews. This does not yet indicate a recurring pattern and may reflect product contamination or individual sensitivity rather than formulation risk; however, recommend monitoring for additional itching/dermatitis reports.
Negative reviews span Jan 2020–Mar 2026
Authenticity — Marketplace Concern
Recurring patternAt least 6 reviews report unsealed, tampered, or visibly altered bottles (missing or wiped-off expiration dates, opened caps, broken seals), and multiple reviewers explicitly state the Amazon product is thicker, darker, smells of glue, or differs materially from the salon version. One reviewer states 'Devoted Creations isn't paired with Amazon' and was told by the brand that Amazon stock is 'not guaranteed.' This indicates a marketplace-integrity and supply-chain issue: either unauthorized resellers, aged inventory, or counterfeit stock is reaching customers. This is not proof the formula itself is unsafe when purchased from authorized sources, but it is a concrete authenticity signal requiring supply-chain investigation.
Negative reviews span Jan 2020–Mar 2026
Based on unverified customer accounts in Amazon review text, not confirmed medical or lab findings.
Avg Rating
3.5★
217 reviews
Positive
56.2%
Rated 4★ or 5★
Neutral
10.6%
Rated 3★
Negative
33.2%
Rated 1★ or 2★
Sentiment Score
62/100
neutral
What Customers Love
Delivers immediate, visible darkening results after just 1-2 tanning bed sessions
“I literally noticed a difference in just my FIRST use! I will definitely keep this one as my lotion, no more searching!”
Achieves a natural brown tan without the orange cast competitors produce
“This one is great!!! It doesn't turn orange at all! I don't understand why other self tanners can't use a brown color to their tanning lotion instead of orange.”
High DHA bronzer intensity creates rich, deep color very quickly for experienced tanners
“I've been tanning for 10yrs on & off in tanning bed, one of my top 2 lotions to use 🖤 doesn't turn me yellow or weird brown”
Excellent value relative to salon pricing ($80+ vs. $30-50 on Amazon)
“This is always been my favorite lotion and now it's even more since I discovered it on Amazon and I don't have to pay 90 bucks a bottle in the salon.”
Customer Feedback
AI summary. Numbers in it are the model’s estimates; counted figures are in Issue evidence below.
Severe, persistent hand and skin staining from cosmetic bronzer that requires immediate washing; stains clothes and towels during application and wearing
Product Failure“I had to wash my hands five or six times right after putting it on just to get it off my hands. It acts like a temporary tan. I tan in high level tanning beds and try different tanning products all the time and I've never used a tanning lotion like this.”
Extremely thick, difficult-to-spread consistency that requires vigorous rubbing and often leaves white, gritty residue or pilling on skin
Product Failure“It doesn't rub in good no matter how well you rub it in. Left gritty patches all over”
Strong, persistent unpleasant odor described as men's cologne, burnt meat, rust, or glue-like smell that lingers hours after tanning
Experience“Smells like my husbands body wash.. did not like for a tanning lotion”
Product arrives unsealed, tampered, or with damaged/wiped-off expiration dates; inconsistencies with salon-version formula
Authenticity“I believe product is old and expired. Devoted creations isn't paired with Amazon. If you match the Devoted Creations products from your local tanning salon and the Amazon product you will see that the one at your local tanning salon is thicker and darker.”
Orange streaking and blotchy discoloration despite 'anti-orange' claims; results wash off within 24 hours in many cases
Product Failure“DO NOT BUY THIS. IT IS A SELF TANNER. No where on the bottle does it even imply that but IT IS. It will stain your hands your clothing, and anything else it comes into contact with.”
Causes itching/scratching and skin sensitivity in some users; one report of hands turning grey/green
Safety“It tans every time, but it made me literally scratch my skin off! Will not use again!”
Issue evidence
How these are countedCounted from this product’s 217 reviews with fixed keyword rules. Click a count to read the reviews.
Complaints (1–3★ reviews)
- Streaking / orange / staining4319.8%Recurring
- Fragrance complaints136%Recurring
- Product effectiveness62.8%Recurring
- Authenticity concerns31.4%Recurring
- Packaging / dispenser31.4%Recurring
- Price / size value20.9%Isolated
Praise (4–5★ reviews)
- Fast, dark results2511.5%Recurring
- Scent customers love209.2%Recurring
- Moisturizing / skin feel62.8%Recurring
- Cheaper than the salon20.9%Isolated
% is the share of all 217 reviews. Recurring means 3+ reviews across 2+ different months. Listing: ASIN B07YRZ18WC
Action Items by Team
Brand Protection & Authenticity (1)
- HIGHAdd a batch lot-code and expiration-date close-up photo to the main listing images — 6+ reviews cite expired, unsealed, or non-salon-matching bottles.
R&D & Product Quality (1)
- MEDIUMFlag DHA concentration and emulsion formula to Formulation & Safety for review — 15+ reviews report it 'turns white'/pastes, 8+ say it won't rub in.
Customer Service (1)
- HIGHReply to reviews mentioning hand staining or thick consistency with a template recommending gloves and 2-3 minutes of rubbing, offering a refund — addresses 45+ reviews.
Listing Content & SEO (2)
- HIGHUpdate listing copy and images to state: 'Contains self-tanning DHA bronzer — stains hands/clothes until washed off. Use gloves during application.'
- MEDIUMAdd a listing warning: 'Best on users with an existing base tan — may appear orange/blotchy on fair skin.' At least 5 reviews report orange cast.
Brand & Positioning Strategy (1)
- LOWReposition 'Orchid Noir' scent as a 'masculine cologne fragrance' in marketing copy — 25+ reviews describe it as men's cologne, helping buyers self-select.
Review Themes
Immediate darkening results, Hand staining issues, Thick, difficult texture, Unpleasant odor, Anti-orange claims questioned, Unsealed/counterfeit bottles, Works for experienced tanners, Poor value perception among dissatisfied customers
Product Details
Key Features
• Ultra-High Levels of High DHA, Natural & Instant Cosmetic Bronzers • Wrinkle Fighting Bakuchiol • Advanced Matrixly Synthe 6 • Spray Tan Friendly Silicones • Detoxifying Charcoal Extracts • Blue Tansy™-Orange Counteracting • Cellulite Fighting and Toning Formula • Tattoo & Color Fade Protecting Technology • Orchid Noir Fragrance
All Reviews
All 217 Amazon reviews for this product are shown here for review · filter by star rating below
Showing 100 of 217 reviews · 5★ only — tap another rating below to switch
Immediate color so wash hands right away
My opion is this is a great lotion because IT DOES STAIN IMMEDIATELY. That said, I apply the product in the bathroom at the salon where I tan becuase if I dont wash my hands right away and wash twice, the likelihood of my hands staining pretty dark is near 100% The color seems to have maybe a violet base where many lotions I've used tend to have a reddish-wannabe-orangy-browish tint. This one is definitely not leaving me orange no matter how often I use it. With regard to how often I use it, I apply some lotion every time I tan. I dont have to use this one every time though because the immediate color lasts and compliments my bed tan by extending the color, even when I go home and shower afterward. I like to use this lotion after shower in place of plain body lotion, again, because of the instant upgrade in color of my skin. The lotion blends with my Swinton well and dries into my skin leaving it feeling soft, smooth, and both looking and feeling hydrated. Unlike other self tanners that make my skin feel dry, this one actually makes my skin feel soft and not hydrated definitely not greasy. Ill order this one again because of the ultra dark instant color that lasts. Buyer do truly beware: wash your hands right away or prepare to have a little darker skintone on your palms. At a minimum, at least wipe the spaces between your difficult gets really well if you do nothing else to remove the product before tanning, then do wash right after your session to minimize color left on your hands.
— Amber
Great dark tanning lotion
This is a great tanning bed lotion. When first using, it did turn my palms colors but after a few uses my hands were used to it and I got dark real fast. Like 3 tanning bed sessions only. My palms did keep a tint for a few days of washes but only at first. Quick results.
— erica
New pick!!
Not thin like Ed Hardys Upgrade to Black. I really love this lotion! It moisturizes good. It smells good, does NOT leave that "smell" after tanning or the skin dry and tight feeling. Also it is pretty dark and I ❤️ that! So this is my new tanning lotion and i have literally tried a bunch of the top reviwed ones but I really love it and I'm happy I tried it!
— Nichole Howard