All Products
Soho Collection· Tingle

WHITE 2 BRONZE TINGLE

“Delivers fast tanning results with no bronzer staining and a pleasant forest-rain scent, though the tingle sensation can be intense for some users.”

Safety — Flagged for Review

Recurring pattern

This is a 'tingle' lotion whose advertised effect is an intense, temporary burning sensation — most reviews describe that burn positively as the reason they bought it, so routine tingle discomfort is not itself a safety concern. Within that context, however, 4 independent reports describe burning beyond the expected effect, requiring immediate removal (one within 2 minutes) and lasting up to 24 hours; 1 report of hives; 1 report of a sun-poisoning-like reaction. Volume is low (4-6 isolated cases across 194 reviews) and does not yet indicate a systemic formula defect, but these are genuine bodily harm complaints that warrant internal review and stricter user-type guidance to prevent future escalation.

Negative reviews span Aug 2017–Apr 2026

Authenticity — Marketplace Concern

Isolated report

8 concrete reports of unsealed or improperly sealed bottles, wrong batch labeling (bottle says 'white to bronze' vs. expected 'white to black'), inconsistent smell and appearance from prior purchases, and one case of clumped product resembling 'cottage cheese.' This is a marketplace/supply-chain integrity issue affecting FBA fulfillment; does not prove the formula is unsafe, but indicates counterfeit or warehouse-damaged stock is reaching customers.

Negative reviews span Aug 2017–Apr 2026

Based on unverified customer accounts in Amazon review text, not confirmed medical or lab findings.

Avg Rating

3.63★

194 reviews

Positive

62.4%

Rated 4★ or 5★

Neutral

7.7%

Rated 3★

Negative

29.9%

Rated 1★ or 2★

Sentiment Score

58/100

neutral

Not enough reviews in Feb 2026–May 2026 (6) for a momentum read

What Customers Love

  • Delivers fast, visible tanning results in fewer sessions

    “I am darker after one session. This is my first time using a tingle lotion and the tingle isn't bad at all”

  • No bronzer means no staining of clothes or hands

    “This lotion is white so there's no worry of staining. Plus the smell is great!”

  • Pleasant fragrance — rain-kissed/forest-like scent

    “The smell is amazing and the tingling sensation is top notch!”

  • Good value for price compared to salon purchases

    “So much cheaper then there personal website it's normally 56$ And it works great”

Customer Feedback

AI summary. Numbers in it are the model’s estimates; counted figures are in Issue evidence below.

  • Extreme, uncontrollable burning pain and physical distress — many users report needing to shower immediately or feeling on fire for hours

    Safety

    “I suffered an excruciating burning pain that would NOT go away. I washed with body soap, then Dawn dish soap”

  • Inconsistent tingle effect — roughly half of 1-2★ reviewers report NO tingle despite advertising as 'intense tingle' product

    Product Failure

    “This lotion sucks... it is advertised as a 'hot' or 'tingle' lotion.. but didn't get any tingle.. might be good for a new tanner!!”

  • Severe skin reactions including hives, blistering, and sun poisoning-like symptoms in isolated but documented cases

    Safety

    “Gave me hives from head to toe. I've never had this happen with a tanning lotion before it was wild.”

  • Multiple reports of unsealed, tampered, or damaged bottles arriving; one case of opened/used product

    Authenticity

    “Bottle was not sealed. I have used this lotion for years and this smell is completely different.”

  • Product causes excessive redness lasting 1-2+ days even with established tanners, making it unpredictable for user skin type

    Product Failure

    “I was red for 2 days. A bright red!!! Do not purchase.”

Issue evidence

How these are counted

Counted from this product’s 194 reviews with fixed keyword rules. Click a count to read the reviews.

Complaints (1–⁠3★ reviews)

Praise (4–⁠5★ reviews)

% is the share of all 194 reviews. Recurring means 3+ reviews across 2+ different months. Listing: ASIN B01MG5XZEP

Action Items by Team

Formulation & Safety (1)

  • LOWFlag internally for discussion: 4 reports of extreme burning, 1 hives, 1 sun-poisoning-like reaction. Escalate for dermatological consult only if monthly complaints exceed 5.

Brand Protection & Authenticity (1)

  • MEDIUMAdd a close-up photo of the proper bottle seal to the listing so customers can verify authenticity — 8+ reviews report bottles arriving unsealed.

Customer Service (1)

  • HIGHReply to reviews mentioning burning or skin reaction with an immediate refund offer and a request for duration/severity details to track patterns.

Listing Content & SEO (2)

  • HIGHAdd a listing warning: 'EXTREME TINGLE — experienced tanners only, not for first-time users. Patch-test on a small area 24 hours before full use.'
  • MEDIUMUpdate the listing to clarify: 'No bronzer — results depend on your skin's melanin response and require an established base tan.' Addresses 15+ 'no color' complaints.

Review Themes

Extreme tingle intensity, Unpredictable effectiveness, Fast tanning results, Unsafe for beginners, Packaging/authenticity concerns, No bronzer — clean hands, Pleasant fragrance, Inconsistent burn sensation

Product Details

Retail Price$49.98
Size8.5 OZ
Usageindoor
Year2017

Key Features

• Intense tingle that allows the skin to go 3 shades darker • Cranberry Seed Oil for added hydration • Rich in Antioxidants • Skin softeners • Anti-aging and firming • Rain Kissed Leaves Fragrance

All Reviews

All 194 Amazon reviews for this product are shown here for review · filter by star rating below

Showing 100 of 194 reviews · 5★ only — tap another rating below to switch

★★★★★Mar 2026

tingles like a mofo!

works amazingly!! pretty hot tingly!!

— Nancy

★★★★★Feb 2021

READ what you’re buying, this is a tingler. It’s different then a regular tanning lotion.

For all the negative reviews, this is a tingler- non bronzer tanning lotion. It’s supposed to make you red and feel burned for hours. Any tanning lotion that says “tingle” will do this. It’s not for everyone. I think it works better for non pale people, so it won’t get too bad. For all you complaining - make sure it does NOT say tingle . It’s just doing what it’s supposed to. Also, to those of you that love it, I suggest a accelerator after, as it moisturizes your skin & the aloe helps the burn. Also hydrates your skin. Also drink plenty of water. Your skin color will be absolutely beautiful with this.

— Kim

★★★★★Dec 2023

Best tanning lotion

I’ve tried quite a few tanning lotions and bronzers always stain my clothes and bedsheets or anything that I gets on so I won’t use those, but since this is a Tingler, it’s the best in my opinion it doesn’t stain whatsoever. Yes, it does burn the first week or so that you use it but your skin will get used to it the lotion brings your blood to the surface of your skin to help you tan and bring out your melanin. I did a lot of research on this cause I was so intrigued of why I was burning so bad, but once you get past the first week, it’s totally worth it because you tan in my opinion at least three times as fast as opposed to without lotion, so I hope this helps at least one person who is like skeptical about trying a Tingler just go for it only tan for like 6-7 min first time with lotion then work yur way up . You also will have a rash or I should say your skin will be blotchy red and burn the next hour after you’re done with the tanning bed but it does go away. I know it sounds like such a pain in the butt it’s all worth it though.

— Gina Maria Stelzer